| YEAR | NAME OF WINNER | CITY, STATE |
| 2010 | Steve Walker & Paul Combs | Defiance, OH |
| 2009 | Jim Garbe | Sylvania, OH |
| 2008 | David Behringer | Defiance, OH |
| 2007 | Doug Mayes | Defiance, OH |
| 2006 | Joel Kin | Defiance, OH |
| 2005 | Ken Hamet | Defiance, OH |
| 2004 | Christopher & Susan Ranieri | Tiffin, OH |
| 2003 | Robert Serrick | Defiance, OH |
| 2002 | Donald B. Ingus | Defiance, OH |
| 2001 | Dave Scott | Defiance, OH |
| 2000 | George Pliakis | Miller Place, NY |
| 1999 | Barb Rosebrock | Ney, OH |
| 1998 | Paul Yoder / Mike McCann | Hicksville, OH |
| 1997 | Mike McBroom | Defiance, OH |
| 1996 | Jack Gregory | Rossville, IL |
| 1995 | Dale Hess | Defiance, OH |
| 1994 | Jim Gillis | Defiance, OH |
| 1993 | Jesse Yates | Ney, OH |
| 1992 | James Panozzo | Calumet City, WI |
| 1991 | Kim Franz | Napoleon, OH |